Lesbian womanliness: Understanding the authenticity and erasure of queer femmes

I

tis the finally times of summer, the night air however comfortable even though sunshine absented itself hrs before. I will be extremely pleased using my dress for all the celebration. Orange blossoms on a navy outfit, nipped in during the waist and full from the sides. Im talking to a female, edgy haircut, large sight. Actually, I’m feeling out the woman queerness. Is actually she gay? Can she inform I’m interested? Would our mouth fulfill carefully, or in a hot, urgent crush?

We’re referring to the queer scene around area whenever she says, off hand, “Yeah, i am constantly hesitant with those a lot more girly lesbians, like – are they

actually

gay?”. I softly alter the topic therefore eventually component ways. I never will understand how the woman human anatomy might feel pressed facing mine. I’m alternatively a familiar flush of alienation clean over myself, a reminder that my personal womanliness remains considered being at probabilities with my queerness. So much so, that to numerous my personal queerness is made illegitimate or undetectable.

It appears in my experience that inside our existing social milieu, masculine and androgynous gender expressions will be the most acceptable and readable forms of queerness. This really is especially the instance for LGBTQIA+ folk whom determine as females and/or non-binary. While queer masculinities tend to be of course good and important, the exclusion of feminine expressions from your communities is in no chance ‘natural’ or ‘inevitable’.

There’s a lot of details because of this situation, all of them contested and limited. Yet in my situation, as a queer lady just who highly identifies with womanliness throughout of its incarnations, background retains the answer to understanding both the validity and also the erasure of womanliness in the queer scene.

F

rom the 1930s until the sixties, United States working class lesbian society was actually ruled by Butch and Femme characteristics. Records from Buffalo and ny from throughout this era suggest that a feminine lesbian or a Femme had been both recognisable and desirable within the lesbian scene.

In Australia, specifically Sydney, gendered roles like Butch and Femme did not come to be section of lesbian’s personal schedules till the sixties. Ahead of this, exact same gender attraction was very taboo that any gender phrase outside feminine norms was actually really impossible for Sydney dependent lesbians. While these scenarios required that expressions of femininity had been mostly recognized within time frame, Femmes happened to be in addition observed by many people as unreliable lesbians very likely to ‘return’ to guys anytime.

The Radical and Lesbian Feminists associated with 1970s forwards got this suspicion of womanliness further, characterising expressions of womanliness as ‘tools regarding the patriarchy’ or signs of ‘male recognition’ – an easy method of labelling female gender expressions as actually oriented towards guys and their desires. These some ideas increased of critiques of patriarchal and capitalist constructions of females as sexual objects when it comes to heterosexual, male gaze.

In practice, this required that lesbians, specifically activists, refused mainstream codes of femininity, opting to leave makeup products in addition to elimination of human anatomy hair to represent their own feminist politics. Critiques of compulsory heterosexuality went hand-in-hand with lots of lesbians’ feminism, which implied that Butch/Femme partners had been criticised for ‘aping’ direct partners. As a consequence, expressions of both masculinity and femininity turned into rejected as anti-radical by some Lesbian Feminist teams.

This rigid viewpoint ended up being declined by many people queers whoever gender expressions, queer and feminist orientations couldn’t squeeze into the androgyny given by some inside the queer area. Certainly, the belated 1980s and 1990s often is referred to as a Butch/Femme renaissance wherein masculine and girly lesbians re-embraced their own sex expressions as parodying and subverting, rather than reproducing, popular or ‘straight’ sex parts. But today the bulk of social and academic operate in the world of lesbian gender appearance stayed dedicated to feminine masculinities. One of many outcomes ­­â€“ presumably accidental – for this re-valorisation of masculinity in lesbians is the sidelining of queer femininities.

This means that queerly feminine people for example myself personally in many cases are hidden in lesbian rooms. Occasionally we’re even unwelcome, regarded as experimenting right girls or as homosexual men’s extras. Without a doubt, it is far from uncommon for a trans guy are more pleasant at a lesbian event than a feminine trans girl.

Yet, Femmes are uniting against our very own erasure, the assumed illegitimacy. You’ll find pouches in the internet and the local gay world where we could get a hold of each other and affirm the queerness. The audience is publishing  anthologies and making art. We’re doing PhDs and creating in Archer. We are getting visible and deafening and proud. Because we have a history, our identities are anchored in the growth of non-binary and female queer politics, tradition and communities.

And by saying this history, we could add our voices to your cacophony of feminine narratives of queerness that decline to end up being sidelined any further.

Katherine Giunta is an Anthropology PhD student researching queer femininities in Sydney. She writes about sex, sex and allyship at the girl web log
katherinegiunta.com
and uses all her funds on This toprated black coffee. You can find this lady on twitter
@pontifi_kate


.